Sunday, February 21, 2010
More on Rainy Mountain
I feel like I do not have that much to comment as of yet on this work. It is interesting, but I cannot formulate much of an opinion. The descriptions are very vivid, and I spoke earlier about it seeming like a journal. I see it as a documentary, or like I am watching the beautiful beginning of a 3-hour dramatic movie. I haven't gotten into the story as yet, but it is still a good experience.
Momaday Video
I thought the video of Momaday was interesting. His speaking is much more coherent than the book we are currently reading. I think it helped to read the book, when I really try to read it as someone speaking about the stories and traditions, rather than reading it as a straightforward novel. Listening to him, I can hear his voice in the book.
Friday, February 19, 2010
Format for Rainy Mountain
I think knowing that this book was not going to be a traditional novel was helpful. I could go into it with little expectation. I see it as a poem, or a journal, or perhaps some other format that cannot even be categorized. It feels like I am walking in the steps of the author.
Sunday, February 14, 2010
Love conquers Death
Page 204 - "The mountain outdistanced their destruction, just as love outdistanced death. The mountain could not be lost to them, because it was in their bones; Josiah and Rocky were not far away. They were close; they had always been close. And he loved them then as he had always loved them, the feeling pulsing over him as strong as it had ever been. They loved him that way; he could still feel the love they had for him. The damage that had been done had never reached this feeling. This feeling was their life, vitality locked deep in blood memory, and the people were strong, and the fifth world endured, and nothing was ever lost as long as the love remained."
Wow! This was an extremely powerful passage that summed up Tayo's healing. He was able to see that even when things look bad, there is always good. He feels connected to this life, while feeling the unseen life. If he sees the circle of life and knows that a spirit can never die, he can release some of the pain and responsibility he feels about his hand in the lives of others. I think some of the purpose of ceremonies is to bring people back to a centering, where they feel that they are important, but not more important than anyone else. We are all a part of this life and play an important role, but we should not think everything is about us.
Wow! This was an extremely powerful passage that summed up Tayo's healing. He was able to see that even when things look bad, there is always good. He feels connected to this life, while feeling the unseen life. If he sees the circle of life and knows that a spirit can never die, he can release some of the pain and responsibility he feels about his hand in the lives of others. I think some of the purpose of ceremonies is to bring people back to a centering, where they feel that they are important, but not more important than anyone else. We are all a part of this life and play an important role, but we should not think everything is about us.
Difficulty
I wanted to take this course to gain some more understanding of my culture and broaden my mind on different ways of writing. At this point, it has been fairly depressing for me to read these stories. They have been a real reflection on a lot of people in my family and how we relate to each other. It has made me think about the things my family and my people as a whole have gone through. I have struggled with many of the same feelings that the characters have expressed, or have heard others speak about them.
Although it is somewhat depressing, I am heartened that non-Natives want to learn about these things and will hopefully go away from an experience like this having more compassion for others.
One of the specific things I am speaking about is the swinging back and forth between arrogance and self-loathing. Many of our people find pride in things which do not bring long lasting glory or benefit. I think we feel like we have to prove to others that we are important, talented or valuable. When reality does not reflect those feelings, we are left worse off than if we had never tried to do something worthwhile. I think some Indian soldiers went to war to prove their courage and intelligence, but ended up having to go against many strongly held beliefs. When you go against your basic self, you can end up feeling lost.
Although it is somewhat depressing, I am heartened that non-Natives want to learn about these things and will hopefully go away from an experience like this having more compassion for others.
One of the specific things I am speaking about is the swinging back and forth between arrogance and self-loathing. Many of our people find pride in things which do not bring long lasting glory or benefit. I think we feel like we have to prove to others that we are important, talented or valuable. When reality does not reflect those feelings, we are left worse off than if we had never tried to do something worthwhile. I think some Indian soldiers went to war to prove their courage and intelligence, but ended up having to go against many strongly held beliefs. When you go against your basic self, you can end up feeling lost.
Sunday, February 7, 2010
American war as opposed to traditional war
I have sometimes wondered why war seems to affect Native men so profoundly. In Ceremony, Tayo appears to be haunted by what he has seen and done. When I think about the things that Native men undoubtedly participated in defending their homes and family over the course of thousands of years, it does not seem to make sense. I'm sure they lived in a vicious and unrelenting environment. However, what I am getting out of the book so far is, in years past, it was an expected, everyday thing to deal with death and hardship. They had a spiritual and physical support system and the things they did were a vital part of maintaining their homes and families.
Going off to fight in an unsupported war, for a country which didn't respect you, seeing things and doing things which had become foreign to them because of the removal from traditional ways of life would be difficult for anyone to handle.
Going off to fight in an unsupported war, for a country which didn't respect you, seeing things and doing things which had become foreign to them because of the removal from traditional ways of life would be difficult for anyone to handle.
Ceremony - The beginning
I really like to read, but this book was a little difficult to get into. It almost felt like reading a dream to begin with. The characters, the scenes, the action all seemed to blur together. I had to start over so that I would get a better sense of what was going on. It still took a while to get used to the different style of writing - the skipping around and the poetry, or what I thought was poetry, but now I see it as that particular author's story. Did anyone else have any difficulties with this?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
