Sunday, May 2, 2010
Lakota Poetry
One other thing on the poetry - it would have been good to see some Lakota poetry, since the class is conducted in South Dakota. Perhaps it would have had to have been more informal. I did a little web searching to see what is out there and did not come up with any formal books, anthologies on first glance, but there were definitely writings which we could have explored as a class, and which I will do on my own at a future time.
Native American Poems
Alexie's "Great American Indian Novel" was pretty funny. It is good to be able to poke fun at ourselves. I thought the part about comparing the Native women to nature was particularly astute. It reminded me of a Sociology class I took where the professor was trying to point out how stereotyped Native women are. He said in the mind, they must all have long hair, they must be riding a horse, in the moonlight, by a stream, and they have to be naked.
Some of the other poems had a definite theme of nature. "The Origins of Corn" and "In the Cornfield" both are speaking of something very natural - food. However, the under lying meanings are more complex. Perhaps that is why the first settlers thought of Native people as simplistic. The way of life may have seemed to have little value, but there was/is a deeper meaning to all that is done. This was a way to pass on morals, traditions and history, but in a more lyrical or magical way.
Some of the other poems had a definite theme of nature. "The Origins of Corn" and "In the Cornfield" both are speaking of something very natural - food. However, the under lying meanings are more complex. Perhaps that is why the first settlers thought of Native people as simplistic. The way of life may have seemed to have little value, but there was/is a deeper meaning to all that is done. This was a way to pass on morals, traditions and history, but in a more lyrical or magical way.
First-NA songs
I did not get much out of the songs on the first reading. I felt like they were very simplistic and repetitive. However, I reread them several times and thought about some of the songs I sing, in particular "church songs". Some of them are very repetitive-repeating a phrase or word over and over. Set to music, I understand the flow of it better. Also, I saw these songs as more of a type of archeology. The compiler was not saying that these were the best, or that this was the most complete anthology available. He simply put them out there. We can look at the songs as a snapshot in Native American culture and history; this is actually what a people group were singing and thinking about at a particular time.
Sunday, April 25, 2010
Alexie
One of the things that show how powerful a writer or writing is, is how long people remember it after, and if it changes the way we think.
Alexie's writing is raw and innocent, beautiful and dirty, anger-inducing and peace bringing. It was thoughtful and encouraging, while at the same time made me want to shake someone.
I cried and laughed and thought, "How did he know what I have thought so many times, but was afraid to say?"
I want to read the rest of his literature.
Alexie's writing is raw and innocent, beautiful and dirty, anger-inducing and peace bringing. It was thoughtful and encouraging, while at the same time made me want to shake someone.
I cried and laughed and thought, "How did he know what I have thought so many times, but was afraid to say?"
I want to read the rest of his literature.
Commonalities
Some of the themes I noticed in the different stories were:
Loneliness - fighting against it (Can I get a Witness, Whatever Happened to Frank Snake Church), giving in (Search Engine, What you Pawn I will Redeem) and finding peace (Do not Go Gentle, Do You Know Where I Am?).
Religion, specifically Catholicism. St. Francis was mentioned several times,
Basketball - this is one of those things that so many people on the reservation invest a large amount of time into, but the payout is rarely ever worth it.
The 9-1-1 Tragedy - in some stories, it is simply a part of the background; that something big and bad happened that we were all a part of. In others, it's integral (Can I get a Witness).
Sex - There were a lot of references to sexual acts, nudity and homosexuality. It seemed a little shocking at first, but considering how big a role it plays in people's everyday lives (particularly our thought lives), it seemed to fit, and eventually made a lot of sense to me to include so much. It really motivates people, destroys and builds up, and is used in love and war.
Loneliness - fighting against it (Can I get a Witness, Whatever Happened to Frank Snake Church), giving in (Search Engine, What you Pawn I will Redeem) and finding peace (Do not Go Gentle, Do You Know Where I Am?).
Religion, specifically Catholicism. St. Francis was mentioned several times,
Basketball - this is one of those things that so many people on the reservation invest a large amount of time into, but the payout is rarely ever worth it.
The 9-1-1 Tragedy - in some stories, it is simply a part of the background; that something big and bad happened that we were all a part of. In others, it's integral (Can I get a Witness).
Sex - There were a lot of references to sexual acts, nudity and homosexuality. It seemed a little shocking at first, but considering how big a role it plays in people's everyday lives (particularly our thought lives), it seemed to fit, and eventually made a lot of sense to me to include so much. It really motivates people, destroys and builds up, and is used in love and war.
Can I Get a Witness
This was a completely unexpected story involving the bomber.
I wondered if we didn't know the two main characters names for a reason.
I also wondered if we were getting her real personality or if she was messed up from the explosion; either a concussion or just disorientation from the trauma.
It seems pretty absurd to just leave with someone, then spend all of that time talking; absurd for both of them. He was trying to help, but at a certain point (sooner), he should have taken her to the hospital. He seems sort of typical in that many people want to help in crisis situations, but don't really have the training or knowledge to assist in tangible ways.
I think she was denying that she was in the restaurant so that she did not have to admit to what she saw or heard. She was probably in shock, so she did not want to have the reality of the situation forced upon her.
I wondered if we didn't know the two main characters names for a reason.
I also wondered if we were getting her real personality or if she was messed up from the explosion; either a concussion or just disorientation from the trauma.
It seems pretty absurd to just leave with someone, then spend all of that time talking; absurd for both of them. He was trying to help, but at a certain point (sooner), he should have taken her to the hospital. He seems sort of typical in that many people want to help in crisis situations, but don't really have the training or knowledge to assist in tangible ways.
I think she was denying that she was in the restaurant so that she did not have to admit to what she saw or heard. She was probably in shock, so she did not want to have the reality of the situation forced upon her.
Saturday, April 24, 2010
Search Engine
This story of Corliss is pretty wry in certain points. "...Corliss figured she could certainly benefit from positive ethnic stereotypes and not feel guilty about it..." This passage about her power, and the fact that she could easily lose that power was enlightening. I want to have a conversation with her.
I agree that it seems if a Native American has assimilated to some degree and is mildly successful, he/she is touted as a great success. It makes me wonder if the things I have accomplished and the awards/compliments I have earned have been because there was no other competition. I have heard numerous times about all the money I have supposedly received from the government for my education and how much easier it must have been for me to get into school.
This has not been the case, but in Corliss's mind, if it had been this way, why not? The government took things away, and in exchange, promised to educate Native people for as long as the sun shone.
The relationship between her and her mother was also pretty poignant. She loves her mother and probably owes her a lot, but wants to be free to be herself. The mother can go from praise to anger very quickly. It seems like a knee-jerk reaction I have experienced from several family members.
Harlan's story about being displaced was also good reading. He feels grateful to the parents who adopted him, but still felt like he had to find his "roots".
There was so much in this short story, that I will probably have to reread it numerous times to get even a long glimpse at its complexities.
I agree that it seems if a Native American has assimilated to some degree and is mildly successful, he/she is touted as a great success. It makes me wonder if the things I have accomplished and the awards/compliments I have earned have been because there was no other competition. I have heard numerous times about all the money I have supposedly received from the government for my education and how much easier it must have been for me to get into school.
This has not been the case, but in Corliss's mind, if it had been this way, why not? The government took things away, and in exchange, promised to educate Native people for as long as the sun shone.
The relationship between her and her mother was also pretty poignant. She loves her mother and probably owes her a lot, but wants to be free to be herself. The mother can go from praise to anger very quickly. It seems like a knee-jerk reaction I have experienced from several family members.
Harlan's story about being displaced was also good reading. He feels grateful to the parents who adopted him, but still felt like he had to find his "roots".
There was so much in this short story, that I will probably have to reread it numerous times to get even a long glimpse at its complexities.
Sunday, April 18, 2010
Imprint
I would highly suggest watching "Imprint". It was released in 2007. Written by a Caucasian South Dakotan, but starring Native Americans. It is a really good story with a really good look at modern Native culture.
Powwow Highway Another look
After Philbert and Buddy get the car stereo put in and cannot get it to work, Buddy's reaction was really out of control. I think it was meant to show that he was hot-tempered and to say that Native people are sometimes taken advantage of, but it just made him look stupid.
I also thought the story about Bonnie was realistic, but not a good portrayal. Drugs are a problem on the reservation and many times the people who are involved with them do not "look" like drug-dealers. So, it was a provocative angle to have the nice looking Native lady with the cute kids arrested. It was also realistic to have the people around her in an uproar about it. It seems like when someone you love has done something wrong, it is easy to overlook the error/crime and blame other people. Buddy and Bonnie's friend were upset with the establishment; Philbert even breaks her out, but what was swept under the carpet was the fact that Bonnie had a large amount of drugs in her car and it was never suggested that it was planted.
I think the writer/director intended to have people look at some of the hardships that Native people undergo, but it seemed like the focus was instead still on the negative.
I also thought the story about Bonnie was realistic, but not a good portrayal. Drugs are a problem on the reservation and many times the people who are involved with them do not "look" like drug-dealers. So, it was a provocative angle to have the nice looking Native lady with the cute kids arrested. It was also realistic to have the people around her in an uproar about it. It seems like when someone you love has done something wrong, it is easy to overlook the error/crime and blame other people. Buddy and Bonnie's friend were upset with the establishment; Philbert even breaks her out, but what was swept under the carpet was the fact that Bonnie had a large amount of drugs in her car and it was never suggested that it was planted.
I think the writer/director intended to have people look at some of the hardships that Native people undergo, but it seemed like the focus was instead still on the negative.
Powwow Highway
This was a different movie for me. I dislike being critical of the "art" of creative endeavors. However, production is important to me. This movie had some good themes (family, traditions, government interference), but the quality of the film was difficult for me. I thought the acting was over the top (the supporting actors were actually more believable) and the plot was too convenient.
Aside from that, the story of the sweet, philosophical man (Philbert) and the loose cannon (Buddy) was a good one. Buddy seemed too focused on his pain and anger to be a legitimate voice for change in his tribe. Philbert maybe needed someone to see him as wise or important; it was funny when they were dropping off the couple and were asked to stay for supper, Buddy said, "No", but Philbert just walked on in. It was Philbert's car, so it was his decision.
The story of Philbert's journey also made me wonder if his interest in traditional/spiritual things is something new, or has he always been a seeker? He seems to have some knowledge of things and the understanding that he needs to speak with elders to gain more, but I wondered what sparked his decision to go on his "quest", since he appears to be a little older.
Ultimately, I don't see a lot of change in either man, but I am left with the hope that the seeds that were planted in each will grow. It does seem like Buddy is more patient, although if it is sincere, or out of necessity is uncertain.
Aside from that, the story of the sweet, philosophical man (Philbert) and the loose cannon (Buddy) was a good one. Buddy seemed too focused on his pain and anger to be a legitimate voice for change in his tribe. Philbert maybe needed someone to see him as wise or important; it was funny when they were dropping off the couple and were asked to stay for supper, Buddy said, "No", but Philbert just walked on in. It was Philbert's car, so it was his decision.
The story of Philbert's journey also made me wonder if his interest in traditional/spiritual things is something new, or has he always been a seeker? He seems to have some knowledge of things and the understanding that he needs to speak with elders to gain more, but I wondered what sparked his decision to go on his "quest", since he appears to be a little older.
Ultimately, I don't see a lot of change in either man, but I am left with the hope that the seeds that were planted in each will grow. It does seem like Buddy is more patient, although if it is sincere, or out of necessity is uncertain.
Sunday, April 11, 2010
Fool's Crow Part 3
This section has much more conflict and caused the most uneasiness for me. In the previous sections and chapters, there were events that made me uncomfortable or sad, but this section ramps up the melancholy.
Fast Horse says in Chapter 20, "Perhaps Owl Child is right. The Pikunis wear the dresses of women. They no longer have the heart to kill off these treacherous insects that steal their land." It is the main argument on one side: the White people are coming and will not stop, they are dangerous and we must fight to stop them.
The other side is: why die needlessly? We can work things out and try to get along peacefully.
This is the argument that has kept mass numbers of people in bondage. The idea that people are basically good and that if we endure, things will be good again is one that evil people in this world will continue to exploit. It happened with the Jews in Nazi Germany, the people at the cult of Jonestown and with the Native people.
We can look back and wonder what would have happened if the Pikunis, Sioux, Navajo, etc. had bonded together and made a serious show of force. Unfortunately, in the moment, most people want peace even if they have to give up something important to gain it.
That is the other part of the giving in; it is by degrees. If the White troops had come in to Indian Country with a large show of force, it would have probably shocked the Plains tribes into action. Instead, there was the semblance of peace and working together, that lulled the tribes into inaction.
Fast Horse says in Chapter 20, "Perhaps Owl Child is right. The Pikunis wear the dresses of women. They no longer have the heart to kill off these treacherous insects that steal their land." It is the main argument on one side: the White people are coming and will not stop, they are dangerous and we must fight to stop them.
The other side is: why die needlessly? We can work things out and try to get along peacefully.
This is the argument that has kept mass numbers of people in bondage. The idea that people are basically good and that if we endure, things will be good again is one that evil people in this world will continue to exploit. It happened with the Jews in Nazi Germany, the people at the cult of Jonestown and with the Native people.
We can look back and wonder what would have happened if the Pikunis, Sioux, Navajo, etc. had bonded together and made a serious show of force. Unfortunately, in the moment, most people want peace even if they have to give up something important to gain it.
That is the other part of the giving in; it is by degrees. If the White troops had come in to Indian Country with a large show of force, it would have probably shocked the Plains tribes into action. Instead, there was the semblance of peace and working together, that lulled the tribes into inaction.
Fool's Crow Part 2
I thought the conversation that Red Paint and White Man's Dog had in chapter eleven about him leaving for war was interesting. I have found that Welch is able, for the most part, to keep the writing realistic for the time, while making it relevant for us.
White Man's Dog speaks about the conflict he feels about leaving, especially because Red Paint's family is not able to properly provide for themselves. He is essentially the "man of the house". She urges him to stay, but he goes on to say that he has chosen the "way of the warrior".
This makes me think of conversations that military families have before someone is deployed. There is a sense of duty to the nation, but there is also the strong pull of family and security. How does one make those kind of decisions? White Man's Dog surely has had a lot of training and informal education on what is expected of men in his tribe. The level of pride is very important as evidenced by him talking about the older warriors getting out of leaving, but for a young man the people would not understand.
White Man's Dog speaks about the conflict he feels about leaving, especially because Red Paint's family is not able to properly provide for themselves. He is essentially the "man of the house". She urges him to stay, but he goes on to say that he has chosen the "way of the warrior".
This makes me think of conversations that military families have before someone is deployed. There is a sense of duty to the nation, but there is also the strong pull of family and security. How does one make those kind of decisions? White Man's Dog surely has had a lot of training and informal education on what is expected of men in his tribe. The level of pride is very important as evidenced by him talking about the older warriors getting out of leaving, but for a young man the people would not understand.
Thursday, March 25, 2010
Fools Crow
The other day I mentioned to a friend of mine that I was reading this book. I simply stated the name and a brief synopsis. She began speaking about the Lakota leader, Fools Crow, who had such a great story; she was happy that I was reading about him. At that point, I didn't know of any other person, so I thought the book was maybe historical. Since then, I found that they are not the same person, so I thought it was weird that Welch would use that name for his book. The real Fools Crow was a spiritual leader who helped end the Wounded Knee standoff in 1973. He spoke to the US Senate and was the nephew of Black Elk, a well-known Lakota leader.
Just like today, where I know numerous "Bills" and "Steves", perhaps there were many plains people who had the same name.
Any thoughts?
Just like today, where I know numerous "Bills" and "Steves", perhaps there were many plains people who had the same name.
Any thoughts?
Sunday, March 21, 2010
Fast Horse's Dream
In the beginning of the book, Chapter 3, page 13, Fast Horse tells the group of men about a dream he had. The men were on their way to steal horses from the Crows. Fast Horse says that "Cold Maker", the Spirit from the cold North, came and spoke to him. Cold Maker told him to find a specific spring and move a boulder from it. Fast horse was also to bring two buffalo robes as a sacrifice at a later date. Cold Maker said if he did this, the raid would go well, but that it would not if Fast Horse failed.
This is one dream in particular which is not told in the first person as it is happening. This tells me that the author, knowingly or not, may have wanted it to appear that Fast Horse was being deceitful. Fast Horse tells the others about his dream, boasting during it. He does not really seek anyone's advice or input. He has a lot of confidence, which seems false, since he supposedly waited 2 days to tell the men.
I don't know if his dream was real, but I believe it was the start of Fast Horse's fall. He may have felt humiliated by the dream not being realized, or thought he could pull a fast one on the others (thinking he'd find a stream with a boulder in it), which did not pan out. Either way, he lost face in a big way, considering what happened to Yellow Kidney. The raid, itself, was successful; the men took a large amount of horses, but leaving Yellow Kidney, with his subsequent mutilation and change in persona, was a huge loss.
I believe that the Pikunis did really have visions, but just like we do now-a-days, they probably had many dreams that were just a result of their hopes and obsessions. Fast Horse was obsessed with ambition and fame, and that could have produced a dream in which he became the leader. Yellow Kidney was probably embarrassed as well, which may have led to him so boldly walking through the camp. He may have felt like he had to do something in order to gain back his edge.
This is one dream in particular which is not told in the first person as it is happening. This tells me that the author, knowingly or not, may have wanted it to appear that Fast Horse was being deceitful. Fast Horse tells the others about his dream, boasting during it. He does not really seek anyone's advice or input. He has a lot of confidence, which seems false, since he supposedly waited 2 days to tell the men.
I don't know if his dream was real, but I believe it was the start of Fast Horse's fall. He may have felt humiliated by the dream not being realized, or thought he could pull a fast one on the others (thinking he'd find a stream with a boulder in it), which did not pan out. Either way, he lost face in a big way, considering what happened to Yellow Kidney. The raid, itself, was successful; the men took a large amount of horses, but leaving Yellow Kidney, with his subsequent mutilation and change in persona, was a huge loss.
I believe that the Pikunis did really have visions, but just like we do now-a-days, they probably had many dreams that were just a result of their hopes and obsessions. Fast Horse was obsessed with ambition and fame, and that could have produced a dream in which he became the leader. Yellow Kidney was probably embarrassed as well, which may have led to him so boldly walking through the camp. He may have felt like he had to do something in order to gain back his edge.
Wednesday, March 17, 2010
Beginning of Fools Crow
So far this book has been very informative concerning tribal traditions and thinking. I am currently taking Lakota Language I, through a tribal college and learning the meaning behind the words has been interesting. The word for school, wowapi, really means the place to read and write. It can also mean education. So, to read the Pikunis call things the wags-the-tail and the Sun Chief is more descriptive than just saying the sun. It makes me wonder about the English language and where those words came from. A lot of them have their base in Latin, which actually did have some sort of meaning to them, but now the words are just words. I also thought about words like, "crack" or "boom", which probably came from someone just making the sounds they heard, and it eventually became the word for it.
Tuesday, March 2, 2010
Kiowa - then and now
After reading this book, I was interested to find out more about modern Kiowas. I wondered why Momaday felt the need to write the Way to Rainy Mountain. Did he write it because he could? Was there a specific reason? Was he writing it to preserve something that was dying, or already gone?
The impression I have is that he had knowledge which was becoming lost. Momaday wanted to pass on the stories he had heard, and felt a responsibility to do it in a respectful and traditional way. He maybe thought he could convey the sense of tradition and mystery by the format in which he wrote, better than trying to tell as many people as he could. It feels very authentic. Someone wrote on the spider poem and that it would not be very comforting. However, if that was the way the story went, he wanted to be consistent with that. The abrupt way the individual stories ended, "He looked for a long time, but there was nothing there." (p. 72) It seems like there should be some moral, or some way that the story is "tied up" at the end, but I think that is the way sometimes with American Indians. People can and maybe should be able to figure out what is being implied.
The impression I have is that he had knowledge which was becoming lost. Momaday wanted to pass on the stories he had heard, and felt a responsibility to do it in a respectful and traditional way. He maybe thought he could convey the sense of tradition and mystery by the format in which he wrote, better than trying to tell as many people as he could. It feels very authentic. Someone wrote on the spider poem and that it would not be very comforting. However, if that was the way the story went, he wanted to be consistent with that. The abrupt way the individual stories ended, "He looked for a long time, but there was nothing there." (p. 72) It seems like there should be some moral, or some way that the story is "tied up" at the end, but I think that is the way sometimes with American Indians. People can and maybe should be able to figure out what is being implied.
Sunday, February 21, 2010
More on Rainy Mountain
I feel like I do not have that much to comment as of yet on this work. It is interesting, but I cannot formulate much of an opinion. The descriptions are very vivid, and I spoke earlier about it seeming like a journal. I see it as a documentary, or like I am watching the beautiful beginning of a 3-hour dramatic movie. I haven't gotten into the story as yet, but it is still a good experience.
Momaday Video
I thought the video of Momaday was interesting. His speaking is much more coherent than the book we are currently reading. I think it helped to read the book, when I really try to read it as someone speaking about the stories and traditions, rather than reading it as a straightforward novel. Listening to him, I can hear his voice in the book.
Friday, February 19, 2010
Format for Rainy Mountain
I think knowing that this book was not going to be a traditional novel was helpful. I could go into it with little expectation. I see it as a poem, or a journal, or perhaps some other format that cannot even be categorized. It feels like I am walking in the steps of the author.
Sunday, February 14, 2010
Love conquers Death
Page 204 - "The mountain outdistanced their destruction, just as love outdistanced death. The mountain could not be lost to them, because it was in their bones; Josiah and Rocky were not far away. They were close; they had always been close. And he loved them then as he had always loved them, the feeling pulsing over him as strong as it had ever been. They loved him that way; he could still feel the love they had for him. The damage that had been done had never reached this feeling. This feeling was their life, vitality locked deep in blood memory, and the people were strong, and the fifth world endured, and nothing was ever lost as long as the love remained."
Wow! This was an extremely powerful passage that summed up Tayo's healing. He was able to see that even when things look bad, there is always good. He feels connected to this life, while feeling the unseen life. If he sees the circle of life and knows that a spirit can never die, he can release some of the pain and responsibility he feels about his hand in the lives of others. I think some of the purpose of ceremonies is to bring people back to a centering, where they feel that they are important, but not more important than anyone else. We are all a part of this life and play an important role, but we should not think everything is about us.
Wow! This was an extremely powerful passage that summed up Tayo's healing. He was able to see that even when things look bad, there is always good. He feels connected to this life, while feeling the unseen life. If he sees the circle of life and knows that a spirit can never die, he can release some of the pain and responsibility he feels about his hand in the lives of others. I think some of the purpose of ceremonies is to bring people back to a centering, where they feel that they are important, but not more important than anyone else. We are all a part of this life and play an important role, but we should not think everything is about us.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
