The other day I mentioned to a friend of mine that I was reading this book. I simply stated the name and a brief synopsis. She began speaking about the Lakota leader, Fools Crow, who had such a great story; she was happy that I was reading about him. At that point, I didn't know of any other person, so I thought the book was maybe historical. Since then, I found that they are not the same person, so I thought it was weird that Welch would use that name for his book. The real Fools Crow was a spiritual leader who helped end the Wounded Knee standoff in 1973. He spoke to the US Senate and was the nephew of Black Elk, a well-known Lakota leader.
Just like today, where I know numerous "Bills" and "Steves", perhaps there were many plains people who had the same name.
Any thoughts?
Thursday, March 25, 2010
Sunday, March 21, 2010
Fast Horse's Dream
In the beginning of the book, Chapter 3, page 13, Fast Horse tells the group of men about a dream he had. The men were on their way to steal horses from the Crows. Fast Horse says that "Cold Maker", the Spirit from the cold North, came and spoke to him. Cold Maker told him to find a specific spring and move a boulder from it. Fast horse was also to bring two buffalo robes as a sacrifice at a later date. Cold Maker said if he did this, the raid would go well, but that it would not if Fast Horse failed.
This is one dream in particular which is not told in the first person as it is happening. This tells me that the author, knowingly or not, may have wanted it to appear that Fast Horse was being deceitful. Fast Horse tells the others about his dream, boasting during it. He does not really seek anyone's advice or input. He has a lot of confidence, which seems false, since he supposedly waited 2 days to tell the men.
I don't know if his dream was real, but I believe it was the start of Fast Horse's fall. He may have felt humiliated by the dream not being realized, or thought he could pull a fast one on the others (thinking he'd find a stream with a boulder in it), which did not pan out. Either way, he lost face in a big way, considering what happened to Yellow Kidney. The raid, itself, was successful; the men took a large amount of horses, but leaving Yellow Kidney, with his subsequent mutilation and change in persona, was a huge loss.
I believe that the Pikunis did really have visions, but just like we do now-a-days, they probably had many dreams that were just a result of their hopes and obsessions. Fast Horse was obsessed with ambition and fame, and that could have produced a dream in which he became the leader. Yellow Kidney was probably embarrassed as well, which may have led to him so boldly walking through the camp. He may have felt like he had to do something in order to gain back his edge.
This is one dream in particular which is not told in the first person as it is happening. This tells me that the author, knowingly or not, may have wanted it to appear that Fast Horse was being deceitful. Fast Horse tells the others about his dream, boasting during it. He does not really seek anyone's advice or input. He has a lot of confidence, which seems false, since he supposedly waited 2 days to tell the men.
I don't know if his dream was real, but I believe it was the start of Fast Horse's fall. He may have felt humiliated by the dream not being realized, or thought he could pull a fast one on the others (thinking he'd find a stream with a boulder in it), which did not pan out. Either way, he lost face in a big way, considering what happened to Yellow Kidney. The raid, itself, was successful; the men took a large amount of horses, but leaving Yellow Kidney, with his subsequent mutilation and change in persona, was a huge loss.
I believe that the Pikunis did really have visions, but just like we do now-a-days, they probably had many dreams that were just a result of their hopes and obsessions. Fast Horse was obsessed with ambition and fame, and that could have produced a dream in which he became the leader. Yellow Kidney was probably embarrassed as well, which may have led to him so boldly walking through the camp. He may have felt like he had to do something in order to gain back his edge.
Wednesday, March 17, 2010
Beginning of Fools Crow
So far this book has been very informative concerning tribal traditions and thinking. I am currently taking Lakota Language I, through a tribal college and learning the meaning behind the words has been interesting. The word for school, wowapi, really means the place to read and write. It can also mean education. So, to read the Pikunis call things the wags-the-tail and the Sun Chief is more descriptive than just saying the sun. It makes me wonder about the English language and where those words came from. A lot of them have their base in Latin, which actually did have some sort of meaning to them, but now the words are just words. I also thought about words like, "crack" or "boom", which probably came from someone just making the sounds they heard, and it eventually became the word for it.
Tuesday, March 2, 2010
Kiowa - then and now
After reading this book, I was interested to find out more about modern Kiowas. I wondered why Momaday felt the need to write the Way to Rainy Mountain. Did he write it because he could? Was there a specific reason? Was he writing it to preserve something that was dying, or already gone?
The impression I have is that he had knowledge which was becoming lost. Momaday wanted to pass on the stories he had heard, and felt a responsibility to do it in a respectful and traditional way. He maybe thought he could convey the sense of tradition and mystery by the format in which he wrote, better than trying to tell as many people as he could. It feels very authentic. Someone wrote on the spider poem and that it would not be very comforting. However, if that was the way the story went, he wanted to be consistent with that. The abrupt way the individual stories ended, "He looked for a long time, but there was nothing there." (p. 72) It seems like there should be some moral, or some way that the story is "tied up" at the end, but I think that is the way sometimes with American Indians. People can and maybe should be able to figure out what is being implied.
The impression I have is that he had knowledge which was becoming lost. Momaday wanted to pass on the stories he had heard, and felt a responsibility to do it in a respectful and traditional way. He maybe thought he could convey the sense of tradition and mystery by the format in which he wrote, better than trying to tell as many people as he could. It feels very authentic. Someone wrote on the spider poem and that it would not be very comforting. However, if that was the way the story went, he wanted to be consistent with that. The abrupt way the individual stories ended, "He looked for a long time, but there was nothing there." (p. 72) It seems like there should be some moral, or some way that the story is "tied up" at the end, but I think that is the way sometimes with American Indians. People can and maybe should be able to figure out what is being implied.
Sunday, February 21, 2010
More on Rainy Mountain
I feel like I do not have that much to comment as of yet on this work. It is interesting, but I cannot formulate much of an opinion. The descriptions are very vivid, and I spoke earlier about it seeming like a journal. I see it as a documentary, or like I am watching the beautiful beginning of a 3-hour dramatic movie. I haven't gotten into the story as yet, but it is still a good experience.
Momaday Video
I thought the video of Momaday was interesting. His speaking is much more coherent than the book we are currently reading. I think it helped to read the book, when I really try to read it as someone speaking about the stories and traditions, rather than reading it as a straightforward novel. Listening to him, I can hear his voice in the book.
Friday, February 19, 2010
Format for Rainy Mountain
I think knowing that this book was not going to be a traditional novel was helpful. I could go into it with little expectation. I see it as a poem, or a journal, or perhaps some other format that cannot even be categorized. It feels like I am walking in the steps of the author.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
